Mater Amabilis™

  • Home
  • Overview
  • Subjects
    • Religion
      • L1B New Testament
      • Level 1B Catechism
      • L1A- A Life of Our Lord for Children
      • L2-Y1- First Christians Reading Schedule
      • L2-Y2-St. Patrick’s Summer
      • Level 3 & 4 Gospel
      • Level 3 Old Testament
    • Language Arts
    • History
      • National History Outline for Australian Students
      • L1B|L1A-This Country of Ours
      • L1|L2-Introduction to American History
        • L1|L2-Further Reading–American History
      • L1|L2-Introduction to British History
        • British History Lesson Plans
        • L2|Y1-Further Reading–British History
        • L2-Our (An) Island Story
        • L2-Introduction to British History for American Students
        • L1|L2-2year-Introduction to British History for British Students
        • L1|L2-3year-Introduction to British History
        • L2-Introduction to British History for British Students – 3 Year Option
        • L1A|L2|L3-Our Lady’s Dowry
      • L1A -Bible History
      • L1A-Ancient Egypt
      • L2-Ancient Greece
      • L2-Ancient Rome
      • Level 3 World History
        • L3-Y1|Y2 – World History Reading List
      • L3-American History
        • L3-From Sea to Shining Sea Reading List
      • L4-20th Century History Update 2024
      • L4-20th Century World History (old)
    • Geography & Earth Studies
      • Introduction to Geography and Earth Studies
      • L1B-Map Location Key
      • L1B-Rivers and Oceans
      • L1A-Weather
      • L1A–Y1– Maps & Mapping
      • L1A-Y1-Earth Studies – Weather
        • British Weather Lore
      • L1A-Y2-Mountains and Volcanoes
      • L3-4 Geography: History of Exploration
      • L4 – Geography of Europe
      • L3|L4-Geology
    • How to Study Shakespeare
      • Shakespeare Plan
      • An Introduction to Shakespeare
      • Comedy of Errors
      • Hamlet
      • Henry V
      • Notes on Julius Caesar
        • Julius Caesar
      • Macbeth
      • Much Ado About Nothing
      • Notes on The Merchant of Venice
        • The Merchant of Venice
      • Notes on The Taming of the Shrew
      • The Tempest
      • Notes on Twelfth Night
    • Science
      • Notes on Nature Study
      • L1B-Nature Study
      • L1A–Y1-Science
        • L1A-Y1-ARCHIVED-Science
      • L1A–Y2-Science
        • L1A–Y2-ARCHIVED- Science
      • L2-Y1-Science In Ancient Greece
      • L2-Y2-Human Body and History of Medicine
      • L3|L4-Science
        • L3-Science Through Time (Secrets of the Universe)
        • L3-ARCHIVED-Science
    • Poetry Plan
      • How to Read a Poem
    • Tales
      • L1A Tales
      • L2 Mythology
      • L3&4 Tales
    • Picture Study
      • Picture Study Resources – All Levels
    • Music Appreciation – All Levels
    • Civics
      • Plutarch
  • Prep Level
  • Level 1B
  • Level 1A
  • Level 2
  • Level 3
  • Level 4
  • High School – Level 5 & 6
    • High School Religion
    • High School English
    • High School History
    • High School Geography
    • High School Science
    • High School Mathematics
    • High School Government, Economics, and Civics
    • On Track to Graduation
    • A Sample Daily Schedule

The Tempest

Commentary by Maria Rioux

Themes:

Familial Love, Romantic Love, Revenge, Freedom, Justice, Mercy

Is Prospero a good father?

Prospero loves his daughter and takes great care with her. He arranges for her to meet and fall in love with Ferdinand (and in this his motives might not be altruistic.. “Was Milan thrust from Milan, that his issue should become kings of Naples?”), and test this man to be assured of his constancy and devotion.

They are both in either’s powers: but this swift business I must uneasy make, lest too light winning make the prize light.

We must bear in mind that Prospero is getting older, he and his daughter are stuck on an island with Caliban, who is hardly trustworthy. I think we can safely assume that Prospero is motivated more by his daughter’s good than any revenge for himself.

I have done nothing but in care of thee. Of thee my dear one, thee, my daughter, who art ignorant of what thou art, nought knowing of whence I am…

Have I, thy schoolmaster, made thee more profit than other princess’ can, that have more time for vainer hours, and tutors not so careful.

We can see further evidence of Prospero’s generous nature in his dealing with Caliban.

I have used thee, filth as thou art, with human care; and lodged thee in mine own cell, til thou didst seek to violate the honour of my child.

A devil, a born devil, on whose nature nurture can never stick; on whom my pains, humanely taken, all, all lost, quite lost; and as with age his body grows uglier so his mind cankers.

Even after Caliban has plotted to dishonor his daughter and to take his life, Prospero pardons him and frees him.

Is Prospero a good man?

Prospero seems to be almost godlike. He commands the elements of nature, is seemingly omniscient, as well as invincible. He frees those in bondage and works to balance the scales of justice. Ferdinand even claims that “By immortal Providence she’s mine…” but we all know who orchestrated this romance. Gonzalo says something similar:

Look down, you gods, and on this couple drop a blessed crown! For it is you that hath chalked forth the way which brought us hither.

We might be tempted to impart base motives to his endeavors and see him simply as a powerful wizard seeking revenge. The text does not support such a conclusion.

At this hour lie at my mercy all mine enemies: shortly shall all my labors end, and thou shalt have the air at freedom: for a little, follow and do me service.

That if you now were to behold them, your affections would become tender.
Dost thou think so, spirit?
Mine would, sir, were I human.
And mine shall. Hast thou, which art but air, a touch, a feeling of their afflictions, and shall not myself, one of their, that relish all as sharply, passion as they, be kindlier moved than thou art? Though with their high wrongs I am struck to the quick, Yet with my nobler reason against my fury do I take part: the rarer action is in virtue than in vengeance: they being penitent, the sole drift of my purpose doth extend not a frown further. (Act V,i, 18-30)

He’s as good as his word:

To work mine end upon their senses, that this airy charm is for…A solemn air and the best comforter to an unsettled fancy, cure thy brains, now useless, boil’d within thy skull!

I do forgive thee, unnatural though thou art.
I will requite you with as good a thing; at least bring forth a wonder, to content ye as much as me my dukedom.

There, sir, stop: Let us not burden our remembrances with a heaviness that’s gone.

The best news is, that we have safely found our king and company; the next our ship, which but three glasses since we gave out split, is tight and yare and bravely rigged, as when we first put out to sea.
Sir, all this service have I done since I went.

This last quote reminds us of earlier mention by Ariel that the shipwrecked men have come to no harm, not even a hair was lost, and their garments are fresher than before these misadventures befell them.

Not a hair perished; On their sustaining garments not a blemish. but fresher than before.

In exacting his revenge, Prospero is uncommonly gentle. His justice is tempered by mercy, which, if we remind ourselves of Portia’s words, is more god-like than man, and he that gives it is twice blest.

The direful spectacle of the wreck, which touched the very virtue of compassion in thee, I have with such provision in my art so safely ordered that there is no soul, No, not so much perdition as a hair betid to any creature in the vessel which thou heardst cry.

In Prospero’s epilogue we have, perhaps, the best insight into his motives and ideals, as well as an inkling of what Shakespeare might have said to his audience could he speak to them in his own person.

But release me from my bands with the help of your good hands:
gentle breath of your my sails must fill, or else my project fails, which was to please. Now I want spirits to enforce, art to enchant; and my ending is despair, unless I be relieved by prayer, which pierces so that it assaults mercy itself, and frees all faults. As you from crimes would pardoned be, let your indulgence set me free.

Was this written to teach or to please?

If we take Shakespeare at his word…and we have no reason not to… his aim was to please. That does not mean that it cannot also teach. However, some methods are more properly ordered to teaching, while others teach almost by way of accident or inference. We recognize the good, the true, and the beautiful, or come to see such things through the artful efforts of one who knows them well.

Lastly, it is interesting to note that Prospero lost his dukedom due in part to too great attention and love for books and learning. He gave his brother too much control and power because he was preoccupied with his studies. Ironically, it is through books that Prospero is restored.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Primary Sidebar

A Catholic Charlotte Mason Homeschool Curriculum

St. Thomas Aquinas & Charlotte Mason

Mater Amabilis

Join us in a private Facebook group for support implementing Mater Amabilis curriculum.

Overview of the Curriculum

VIEW HERE

Getting Started Guide

Click here to download and print our helpful guide to getting started with Mater Amabilis ™ curriculum.

Helpful Resource Pages

Religion

Language Arts

History

Science Overview

How To Study Shakespeare

Nature Study

Geography & Earth Studies

Picture Study

Music Appreciation

Plutarch

Search MA

Amazon Affiliate

This site contains links to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate, Maureen Wittmann earns affiliate income from qualifying purchases made through linked purchases from this site. We are grateful for your support which goes toward the maintenance and upkeep of Mater Amabilis.

Mater Amabilis

“. . . our Blessed Virgin Mary is called Amabilis, or lovable, as being such to the children of the Church.” -Bl. John Henry Cardinal Newman

Copywork Made Clear

Here is a new video on the value and process of copywork.

A Tour of the MA website

Here is a brief tour through the website, including how to find the introduction, overview, subject helps, and level landing pages. We have also included a tour of level 1A as an example of the resources available for most levels, and a quick look at the high school levels.

The Joy of Copywork

by Sally Thomas I’ve always loved copywork. In grade school, the nicest days – aside from the days when the art teacher read us Amelia Bedelia – were the days when the teacher handed us a poem, purple, damp, and vaguely vanilla-scented, fresh from the ditto machine. Generally it was a poem of the season, … Read More about The Joy of Copywork

Mater Amabilis gratefully accepts donations toward the maintenance of the site.

Privacy Policy

Mater Amabilis does not collect, use, or store data from visitors.

Third parties (including Amazon and any other site we link to) MAY collect, use, or store data from visitors, and place or recognize cookies on visitors’ browsers. We are not responsible for the content or privacy practices of such other sites. We encourage our users to be aware when they leave our site and to read the privacy statements of any other site that collects personally identifiable information.

Disclosure:

Mater Amabilis is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to offset fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Usage:

Copyright © 2003 – 2022. All Rights Reserved. Use of this material is subject to the terms of the Mater Amabilis™ License Agreement.

Use of the Mater Amabilis™ name and/or image is not permitted without written permission.

Follow us on Social Media

Copyright © 2025 · Mater Amabilis